MedEntry

Trusted UCAT prep.

Discrimination in university admissions?

campus_329767535720x480

What is discrimination?

Discrimination can be defined as unwarranted unfavourable treatment towards an individual or groups of individual based on their actual or perceived membership in a certain group or social category. Such treatment is usually in a way that is worse than the way people are usually treated. Discrimination could be based on someone’s gender, race, location, or socio-economic basis, etc. Discrimination is against the law under the Discrimination Act 1991 (ACT), Anti-Discrimination Act 1977 (NSW), Anti-Discrimination Act 1996 (NT), Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (QLD), Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (SA), Anti-Discrimination Act 1998 (TAS), Equal Opportunity Act 1995 (Vic) and Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (WA). It is said there is some bias towards interstate students during medical interviews in some universities. This article aims to explore the legal basis behind discrimination using the ACT provisions, the possible bias against interstate students and suggest some future change. 

Legal basis

Discrimination legislation:

Section 7(2) of the Discrimination Act 1991 (ACT) sets out a test for discrimination. It states whether there is discrimination on the basis of a “characteristic that people with attribute generally have”. Section 8(1) deals with direct discrimination. Section 8(2) however, provides that a condition or requirement that would otherwise be discriminatory is not unlawful if it is ‘reasonable in the circumstances’. 

The Australian Constitution: 

Section 117 of the constitution provides that ‘A subject of the Queen, resident in any state, shall not be subject in any other state to any disability or discrimination which would not be equally applicable to him if he were a subject of the Queen resident in such other state”. This means that residents in any states should not be subject to discrimination of any form regardless of where they are from. 

Admission of interstate students

It is said there is a certain amount of bias towards interstate students during medical interviews. Some universities tend to place interstate students in 2nd round interviews, and give their 1st round interviews to local students. Whilst such actions may be viewed purely as convenience for both students and interviewers, it can also be argued the lack of interstate students in 1st round interviews constitutes discrimination. 

Ideally, admission should be based on the candidate’s own merits, personal achievements and suitability to the profession rather than the state they come from. Since Australian MBBS graduates are specifically trained for the Australian medical system, they represent the best return on investment by the Commonwealth and State or territory governments, which fund medical students’ education and internships. It is currently unknown whether there would be a reason that could be deemed as “reasonable” to give priority to local students. Likely, there is no reason to discriminate students based on their state of origin. This is most likely unconstitutional and against the provisions of Anti-discrimination legislation. 

Future change

If such discrimination and bias is occurring against interstate candidates, this is a problem that university admissions boards needs to investigate into. Solutions should aim at devising a system that does not allow bias against interstate students. 

 

Sample MMI question: A Contemporary Issue Scenario
Making Friends with UMAT Practice
UMAT tips USyd UMAT Exam Discrimination MedEntry LMS Update HPAT UMAT Problems Sample Interview Questions UMAT compared to school MMI Ethical Dilemma Questions Free UMAT questions UCAT Tips UCAT Exam UMAT UCAT Training UMAT Courses Toowoomba UMAT Skills UMAT Courses Darwin mmi scoring UMAT Test tactics UCAT Preparation UMAT Tutoring UMAT anxiety Multistation Mini Interviews UCATSEN UCAT Date Multiple Choice umat 2019 UCAT Study UMAT Courses UMAT resources ACER UCAT Timing UMAT Workshops Sample UMAT Questions UNSW UCAT Prep 2019 UCAT Registrations University fees University Entrance Interview Applications UCAT UCAT App UMAT Queensland UCAT Stress University Rankings UMAT vs ATAR UMAT Forums HPAT Preparation mmi sample question Psychometric tests UCAT 2019 UMAT Practice UMAT Prep UMAT Stress Which Uni? English UMAT Preparation Medicine at Melbourne Year 12 UMAT questions UMAT Results UCAT Test Tips LMS Updates Online UMAT Prep UMAT Coaching Counting Problems Speed Reading in UCAT UCAT Situational Judgement Test Situational Judgement Test UCAT Anxiety UMAT Section 1 Logical Reasoning & Problem Solving Study Tips UCAT Test Process of Elimination UCAT Coaching UCAT Booking mmi ethical dilemma UCAT Test Date Video Blog Careers Teachers UMAT Coaching Sydney UMAT Test Tips UMAT Motivation LMS Update Active learning UMAT Training UCAT Scores UCAT Course Medical Entrance UMAT Preparation Courses UMAT Test UCAT exam UCAT Preparation Courses Medicine UCAT Results UMAT Study UCAT Practice UMAT Tuition Medicine at Monash UMAT scores GAMSAT mmi sample answer UCAT Practice Test Interview Questions UMAT advice Medical Interview Resilience UMAT Courses New Zealand UMAT Section 3 Non Verbal Reasoning Studying Medicine UCAT Registration Speed Reading in UMAT Pearson VUE UCAT Abstract Reasoning Time Management Probability UCAT advice UMAT Practice questions UCAT workshop Percentage questions Sample MMI UMAT Section 2 Understanding People

trhdtre tre



Get our new Free UCAT Practice Exam!