MedEntry

Trusted UCAT prep.

NOT ALL ENTRY TESTS EQUAL, Medical Observer (16 February 2007, Page 17)

The debate about whether school leaver entry or graduate entry is better for medicine will continue for a long time because there are winners and losers in either scenario (Inside Story, 24/11/2006; Letters, 8/12). The graduate entry pathway has the following disadvantages:

1. Many highly able students who would otherwise have become excellent doctors will be lost to other professions, because they may be reluctant to obtain another degree after graduation.

2. Graduate medical programs reduce the productive working life of a doctor.

3. The longer duration of study is likely to result in increased cost of services to patients on graduation and higher costs to tax payers to subsidise their study.

4. A significant proportion of school leavers are mature enough to make career choices. Our evidence is that over 99% of Year 12 students prefer to go straight into Medicine rather than do an irrelevant degree. Forcing them to do a degree in which they have no interest in, and see it only as a means to an end, will result in frustration and lead to increased unethical conduct during assignments/exams, such as copying and plagiarism.

5. Graduate Medical programs make medical education backtrack 50 years. Back then, students in medical schools spent the first three years learning basic medical sciences with no patient contact, and only afterwards spent time in hospitals seeing the relevance of what they previously learnt. This is effectively what a Graduate Medical program involves. The current worldwide trend of Problem Based Learning in undergraduate medical entry avoids this problem, with students learning biomedicial sciences 'just-in-time', which makes the learning process relevant, interesting and memorable.

6. If a student completes a biomed/science degree with the intention of pursuing medicine and is later unsuccessful in obtaining a place in medicine, what career options are available? Students are lured into a science degree by universities keen to bolster their flagging enrollments in science faculties, with disregard for the career aspirations of students.

While school leaver entry is better for everyone, a small proportion of medical places (say 10%) may be set aside for graduate entry. Graduate medical places can be an option for those who are uncertain about their career choice, unprepared for tertiary study or were unable to obtain a place after year 12.

However, there is a problem with the entry test for graduates. If practicing doctors in Australia were to sit the tests without preparation, at least 70% would pass the UCAT (test for school leavers), whereas only about 1% would pass the GAMSAT (test for graduates). This is not because GAMSAT is harder than UCAT: it is because while UCAT tests generic skills, GAMSAT tests knowledge, much of which is irrelevant to the practice of medicine.

Sample MMI medical interview question: an ethical ...
MEDICAL TRAINING, The Education Age (21 November 2...

By accepting you will be accessing a service provided by a third-party external to https://www.medentry.edu.au/

Receive the latest UCAT news and tips in your inbox

Sign up for the MedEntry Newsletter

Verbal Reasoning Tips Medicine at Monash UCAT App UCAT UCAT 2021 Registration mmi ethical dilemma UCAT Training AR Trainer UCAT vs GAMSAT Ethical Dilemma Questions Future UCAT Students UCAT VR mmi scoring UCAT Calculator UCAT Question Bank mmi sample question Pearson VUE UCAT advice Interview Speed Reading in UCAT UCAT Percentile Calculator LMS Update First year of Medicine UCAT Date Applications UCAT Test Tips UCAT Abstract Reasoning English Rural Students UCAT & COVID lockdown Bond University Medicine Time Management MedEntry LMS Update UCAT Highest Results LMS Updates Bond Psychometric tests UCAT 2022 Year 12 UCAT 2019 UCAT Timing UCAT Exam Experience ucat tutoring Situational Judgement Test UCAT weekly classes Percentage questions UCAT Course UCAT Forums UCAT workshop Resilience Medicine Application advice Free UCAT Prep UCAT Situational Judgement Test UCAT Venue ucat mindset Coronavirus Medical Entrance UCAT Registrations Charity Partner Medicine at Melbourne Free UCAT Practice Exam Process of Elimination Medicine USyd Multiple Choice UCAT Preparation mmi sample answer UCAT Test Venue UCAT Tutor MedEntry Free Trial LMS Forums Careers Teachers UCAT Registration UCAT Tips HPAT Preparation UCAT speed reading Sample Interview Questions Medical Schools Sample MMI MedEntry Skills Trainer ucat motivation UCAT Online Multistation Mini Interviews Medicine at UNSW UNSW UCAT Test Venn Diagrams UCAT Preparation Courses Work Experience UCATSEN Probability UCAT VR Tips GAMSAT UCAT Exam Tips UCAT Coaching Provisional Entry UCAT Prep Distributed Practice OLP Updates UCAT 2020 Tips Counting Problems Forums Studying Medicine Discrimination HPAT Video Blog University Rankings ucat Decision making UCAT Free Trial Which Uni? 2020 UCAT Registrations medical entry UCAT Practice MedEntry Medicine preferencing UCAT 2021 Results Study Tips How to Use the UCAT Calculator UCAT Workshop UCAT Health Medical Interview MedEntry UCAT Workshop UCAT Advice UCAT Percentile UCAT Key Dates UCAT Noteboard Active learning UCAT Test Date UCAT 2021 Virtual Medical Interview UCAT Experience Charity UCAT Trainer ucat tuition UCAT 2020 Registrations TAC Application Medical Interview Training UCAT ANZ 2021 UCAT tips UCAT Results UCAT Scores Interview Questions UCAT Study Medicine at Sydney University UCAT Booking University Entrance MedEntry Calculator MMI UCAT Stress COVID-19 UCAT Books MedEntry Community Page UCAT exam University fees News UCAT 2020 UCAT Memes UCAT Practice Test Graduate entry medicine UCAT Video Guides UCAT Skill Trainers Psychometric tests UCAT Preliminary Statistics UCAT Exam ucat secrets UCAT Anxiety ucat mindet Bonded Medical Program ucat guessing

trhdtre tre